You are selling something. The buyer sends a cheque or transfer for more than the agreed price, explains it as an error or as covering a shipping agent, and asks you to return the difference. Your bank shows the funds. You refund the excess. Weeks later the original payment is reversed as fraudulent and you are liable for the whole amount.
Available is not cleared
Banks commonly make funds available before a payment is irrevocable. With cheques in particular, the instrument can be returned long after the money appeared in your balance. The same applies to some transfers later found to be fraudulent. Availability is a convenience, not a guarantee of settlement.
Where it appears
- Private sales of vehicles, equipment and high-value items.
- Freelance and contracting work, where an overpayment is framed as covering a subcontractor.
- Rental deposits paid in excess with a request to refund the difference.
- Employment scams where a new hire is sent funds to purchase equipment from a specified supplier.
The rule
Never return any part of a payment until the original is unconditionally settled. Ask your bank directly: "When does this become irrevocable?" and wait. A genuine buyer who overpaid by accident can wait a few days. A fraudster will apply pressure, which is itself the confirmation.
If it has happened
Tell your bank immediately — early disclosure affects how the resulting debt is handled. Report to the police and the national fraud body. Keep the original instrument, the correspondence and the refund record. Where an employer or platform was involved, tell them too, as the same script is usually being run against others.